Formulating with Alternative Oils: What You Need to Know
Switching oil sources, or developing a new product with an alternative oil, requires more than a label change. It demands a holistic view of how the oil behaves in your product, how it interacts with other ingredients, and how it holds up over time. Here are key considerations:
1. Oil Stability
Oxidative and hydrolytic rancidity are primary concerns. While predictive tools like the Oxidative Stability Index can offer early insights, real-world shelf-life studies with chemical and sensory evaluations remain the gold standard. If you're removing both seed oils and synthetic antioxidants, expect a more complex formulation landscape. Natural antioxidants like mixed tocopherols or rosemary extracts can help, but they may not match the performance of BHA or EDTA especially in metal-rich environments.
2. Shelf-Life Extension
Packaging, antioxidants, and formulation tweaks all play a role. Oxygen, light, and trace metals accelerate oxidation, so barrier packaging and low-oxygen headspace (e.g., nitrogen flushing) may be necessary. While synthetic antioxidants like TBHQ are highly effective, many brands are turning to natural alternatives though these often require higher usage rates and tighter process controls.
3. Frying Performance
Smoke point matters. If your product involves frying, oil refinement level and composition will dictate performance. Refined avocado oil, for example, offers high heat stability, while unrefined oils, though richer in antioxidants, may degrade quickly under heat.
4. Texture and Structure
Solid fat content, melting point, and crystallization behavior all influence texture. Products like baked goods, confections, and spreads may require reformulation to maintain structure and prevent oil migration. In some cases, matching the performance of traditional fats like palm or cocoa butter may not be feasible without blends or functional additives.
5. Flavor Impact
Oils are not neutral. They carry their own flavor profiles and influence how other flavors are perceived. While refined seed oils offer a blank canvas, alternative oils especially unrefined can introduce strong notes that may or may not align with your product’s sensory goals.
Global Sourcing and Supply Chain Risks
Alternative oils often come with international sourcing dependencies. This introduces variables like pesticide compliance, import detentions, and geopolitical risk. For example, unauthorized pesticide residues can trigger FDA Import Alerts, halting shipments and requiring costly remediation. As demand for niche oils grows, so does the risk of supply chain instability and unvetted suppliers.
Adulteration and Authenticity
Adulteration becomes a significant concern when demand for alternative oils outpaces supply. Olive oil, for example, is highly sought after and commands a premium price, making it one of the most economically adulterated food products globally. Common practices include partial or complete substitution with lower-cost vegetable oils such as sunflower, soybean, or canola. Additionally, mislabeling lower-grade oils as "Extra Virgin" is a frequent issue. While blending may seem like a minor cost-saving measure, it introduces serious vulnerabilities that can lead to regulatory violations and food safety risks. To evade detection, fraudsters often manipulate oil characteristics, such as adding chlorophyll to mimic expected color, making adulteration increasingly difficult to identify. Ensuring authenticity requires careful attention to testing methods and a strong understanding of the complexities involved in oil verification
Natural Does Not Mean Risk-Free
While alternative oils may align with clean-label goals, it's important to recognize that “natural” does not automatically mean safe or free from risk. Many plant-derived oil sources contain naturally occurring antinutrients and toxins, such as erucic acid, gossypol, phytic acid, lectins, and saponins. These compounds are often reduced or eliminated through processing, but their presence underscores the need for thorough safety assessments, especially when working with novel or less common oil sources.
In addition to inherent compounds, environmental and processing-related contaminants must be considered. Oils can carry residues of aflatoxins, mycotoxins, residual solvents, PCBs, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), mineral oils, and MCPD esters or glycidol. Because many of these contaminants are lipophilic, they tend to concentrate in oils during extraction. Even low-level exposure from growing conditions or equipment can lead to regulatory scrutiny or unexpected quality issues.
As global sourcing expands to meet demand for alternative oils, enhanced diligence is essential. Understanding the safety profile, regulatory status (such as GRAS), and contaminant risks of each oil source is critical to maintaining product integrity and avoiding costly surprises.
Are Alternative Oils a Practical Path Forward?
Exploring alternative oils is an exciting direction for product innovation, sustainability, and clean-label reformulation. But while the rationale may be sound, the practical realities are more complex. Choosing to shift away from conventional oils like soybean or canola is one thing executing that shift across formulations and processing systems at scale is another.
Consider the supply dynamics: global production of olive oil is approximately 3 million metric tons, while soybean oil exceeds 60 million. That’s not just a difference in volume, it’s a fundamental challenge in sourcing, cost, and formulation compatibility. Bridging that gap requires more than enthusiasm; it demands strategic planning, technical expertise, and a deep understanding of how alternative oils behave in real-world applications.
Final Thoughts
Alternative oils offer exciting possibilities, but they also introduce formulation, sourcing, and regulatory complexities that can’t be overlooked. Success depends on a thoughtful, data-driven approach that balances innovation with functionality and risk management.
If you're exploring a shift in oil strategy, partner with experts who understand the full picture from oxidative stability to global sourcing to label claims. Because in the world of oils, what you don’t know can hurt your product.
Start the Conversation
Ready to get started? Eurofins can help.
Additional Resources
Seed Oils Under Scrutiny: What the MAHA Report Means for Food Manufacturers
Reformulating with Confidence: Why Analytical Testing Is Essential for Natural Color Transitions
Meet the Author
Dan Berg
Senior Analytical Services Manager | Eurofins Food Chemistry Testing Madison
Dan Berg has a BS and MS in Food Chemistry from the University of Wisconsin - Madison. He has over 25 years of food industry experience in Quality Assurance, Aseptic Processing, Research and Development, and Technical Services especially related to starches, sweeteners and fiber ingredients. He is currently Senior Analytical Services Manager for Eurofins Food Chemistry Testing Madison. In his role, he helps design and facilitate analytical testing programs for clients across the food industry, with a focus on nutritional and chemical contaminant analysis. Dan is a Certified Food Scientist, active in the Institute of Food Technologists and International Society of Beverage Technologists and has held a variety of committee leadership roles in those organizations.
